The burden of proof
The burden of proof on the date of construction can only fall on the interested party: he alone, in fact, in compliance with the principle of proximity of the instruments of proof (art. 2697 civil code), can provide irrefutable deeds, documents and evidentiary elements that are able to establish the reasonable certainty of the time of construction of an artefact(1), while the Administration cannot, usually, materially ascertain in detail what the construction situation was within its territory(2).
The aforementioned orientation has received yet another confirmation from the TAR Lazio, Rome, section. II quater, in the sentence. 9 September 2026, n. 14719 and of the Council of State, sec. II, in the sentence. 7 October 2026, n. 7381.
The Roman judges, in particular, reiterated that “the burden of proof regarding the completion of the works at a time prior to a certain date (in this case, in the period prior to 1967) lies with the applicant, in whose sphere of lordship, as responsible for the abuse or owner, the conduct falls (…). This allocation of the burden of proof cannot fail to also concern the fundamental profile relating to the demonstration of the actual pre-existence of the works carried out compared to the time, 1967, when the obligation to obtain the qualifying title came into force; and this also in compliance with the CD. “principle of proximity of proof”, by virtue of which the owner is reasonably required to produce documentary evidence aimed at proving that the abusive conduct carried out on the property has been “consumed” by the aforementioned date (…) and has precisely the morphological and planivolumetric characteristics subsequently ascertained (…)”.
Similarly, the judges of the Council of State confirmed, recalling their own precedents(3), that “In the presence of a demolition order, the burden of demonstrating that the works are legitimate having been carried out legitimately without a title before 1967, so that they are among those for which a title was not required ratione temporisfalls on the private individual concerned, the only person to have documents and evidence available, capable of demonstrating with reasonable certainty the time of creation of the artefact”.
The characteristics of the test
The proof must be rigorous and based on certain and unambiguous documentation and, in any case, on objective elements, concerning not only the dating of the artefact but also its specific consistency, as it may have changed over time (4), with the consequence that any uncertainty can only redound to the detriment of the private individual (5).
For example, for the purposes of demonstrating a pre-1967 rural building, the following were considered sufficient(6): the stacking and subdivision of the building on the pre-1967 parcel; a public deed dated 06.07.1967 from which the existence of the aforementioned real estate was evident; a technical report which analytically reconstructed the history of the building identified with the parcel, registered in the year 1925; a technical report which highlighted the structural connection of the works included in the parcel.
Examples of insufficient evidence to satisfy the evidentiary burden
The reported ruling of the Council of State also focuses on some elements which, presented by the private individual concerned, were deemed insufficient to satisfy the burden of proof falling on the latter:
- a user license issued by the Prefecture in 1963, as nothing could emerge from it regarding the actual consistency of the works created;
- two aerial photogrammetries without a certain date;
- biased technical consultancy, as it is not useful in the absence of precise, serious and consistent elements.
Among recent cases, we would like to remind you that the following were considered insufficient from an evidentiary point of view:
- the seller’s declaration on the date of construction of the property in question included in the sales deed (7);
- a photo attached to an application but without certain elements, which can only be useful to certify the state of the property on the date of the application and not in a previous period (8);
- undated photos(9);
- aerial photos of the IGM and photographs after the date to be tested(10);
- a private deed, without a certain date, concerning the preliminary contract for the sale of land by the father of the current owner(11);
- testimonial evidence in the absence of substantial circumstantial elements and the declaration of the interested party’s spouse(12);
- a will published before 1967 which contained no mention of the property in question(13).
Notes
(1) Council of State, sec. VI, sentence. 19 January 2026 n. 403; section IV, sentence. 19 March 2025, n. 2262; TAR Lazio, Latina, sec. II, sentence. 24 January 2026, n. 45; section I, heard. 11 March 2025, n. 193; TAR Lombardy, Milan, section. IV, sentence. 21 October 2025, n. 3342; sent. 9 June 2025, n. 2065; sent, 14 April 2025, n. 1326; TAR Calabria, Reggio Calabria, sentence. 14 October 2025, n. 661; TAR Campania, Salerno, section. II, sentence. 16 January 2025, n. 83.
(2) TAR Abruzzo, L’Aquila, sec. I, heard. 23 January 2026, n. 40.
(3) Council of State, sec. VI, sentence. 27 January 2022, n. 570; section II, sentence. 5 February 2021, n. 1109; section VI, sentence. 13 December 2019, n. 8475 and sent. 5 March 2018, n. 139.
(4) TAR Calabria, Reggio Calabria, sentence. 14 October 2025, n. 661.
(5) TAR Lazio, Latina, sec. II, sentence. 24 January 2026, n. 45; sent. 25 August 2025, n. 695; sent. 8 February 2025, n. 77.
(6) TAR Campania, Salerno, sec. II, sentence. 16 January 2025, n. 83.
(7) TAR Lazio, Latina, sec. II, sentence. 24 January 2026, n. 45: in the specific case, the declaration affirmed that construction had taken place before 1967.
(8) TAR Lazio, Latina, sec. II, sentence. 25 August 2025, n. 695. Council of State, sec. IV, sentence. 19 March 2025, n. 2262; see also TAR Lazio, Latina, section. I, heard. 2 March 2022, n. 207: on the occasion it was specified that no value can be attributed to a “color photograph without a certain date, which portrays a child in a vegetable garden with a building in the background and handwritten notes as comments”.
(9) TAR Lombardy, Brescia, sec. II, sentence. 1 July 2024, n. 583.
(10) TAR Campania, Salerno, sec. II, sentence. 31 October 2024, n. 2039.
(11) TAR Lombardy, Milan, sec. IV, sentence. 9 June 2025, n. 2065.
(12) Council of State, sec. VI, sentence. 15 January 2025, n. 309: “In fact, with regard to the range of evidentiary tools admissible for the purposes of proving the moment in which the abuse occurred, a consolidated jurisprudential orientation holds that self-declarations cannot be used in the administrative process and that they do not have any effective probative value, as they can only constitute evidence which, in the absence of other new, precise and concordant elements, are not ex se suitable to undermine the investigation activity of the administration – that is, the deductions with which the administration itself finds the unreliability of what is represented by the applicant – (see, ex multis, Cons. Stato, Section IV, 29 May 2014 n. 2782 and 27 May 2010 n. 3378).
And in fact, even in the presence of a declaration in lieu of an affidavit, where no elements are found which unequivocally demonstrate the completion of the building by the date set by law, given that the said affidavit cannot rise to the rank of proof, even presumptive, on the time of the abuse – proof regarding the certain date of completion of the works cannot be considered to have been achieved (see State Council, Section IV, 24 December 2008 no. 6548).
And furthermore, as stated by the jurisprudence, “In the absence of substantial circumstantial elements, the testimonial evidence, in light of its margins and the cautions that surround it, cannot find entry” (see Cons. Stato, Sez. VI, 25 September 2024, n. 7770 and jurisprudence referred to therein: Cons. Stato, Sez. VI, 5 March 2018, n. 1391)”.
(13) TAR Campania, Salerno, sec. II, sentence. 4 November 2024, n. 2062.
In collaboration with studiolegalepetrulli.it