Formal abuse and substantial abuse: the current rules
To understand the scope of the proposals under discussion, it is necessary to distinguish between what the legal system already allows for regularization when fully implemented and what today remains incurable. Even after the innovations introduced by the Save Home Decree (DL 69/2024, converted by law 105/2024), the ordinary amnesties provided for by Presidential Decree 380/2001 – from the assessment of conformity of the art. 36 to the new regime of the art. 36-bis for partial discrepancies and essential variations, up to art. 37 for interventions subject to SCIA – concern exclusively formal abuses.
Based on the rules in force, a work created without a title or in non-conformity can only be remedied if it still respects the regulatory plans, intended uses and volumetric indices at the time of submission of the application. If an intervention has led to an increase in volume beyond the limits permitted by the Municipality or has violated the urban planning regulations of the area, today there is no ordinary path to regularize it.
The reopening of the 2003 amnesty would intervene precisely on this issue, introducing an extraordinary exception to the urban planning instruments to also remedy substantial abuses, i.e. volumes and new real estate units built in contrast with the regulatory plans. However, the deadline of 31 March 2003 for carrying out the abuses would remain fixed.
The temporal perimeter, no amnesty for recent abuses
The hypothesis being examined by the majority, in fact, would not provide for a new general amnesty for interventions carried out in the last twenty years, but the reopening of the deadlines for submitting applications relating exclusively to illegal works completed by 31 March 2003. It is therefore not a question of moving the completion date forward, but rather of opening a new time window for the applications left out in 2003-2004.
The initiative was born from the need to unblock the situation of the Regions which at the time did not implement the state regulation of the third amnesty, leaving tens of thousands of demolition procedures and orders pending, starting from the case of Campania. To avoid profiles of unconstitutionality linked to an intervention limited to a single territory, the orientation that has emerged in the last few hours aims to extend the reopening on a national scale, thus also involving owners from other Regions who did not submit applications within the original deadlines for properties completed before 31 March 2003.
The hypotheses under discussion and the limits of the art. 32 of Legislative Decree 269/2003
If the installation of the art. 32, paragraphs 26 to 50, of Legislative Decree 269/2003 were re-proposed without substantial changes, all the original technical limitations would remain unchanged:
- Volumetric limits: the extraordinary amnesty would concern expansions within 30% of the original volume or in any case not exceeding 750 cubic meters, and new residential buildings up to 750 cubic meters per single application (with an overall limit of 3,000 cubic meters per building), always provided that the property complies with anti-seismic technical standards.
- Constraints and excluded areas: the absolute exclusions would remain confirmed for works carried out on areas subject to restrictions of absolute non-buildability, cultural heritage, areas affected by fires, maritime or river state property and civic uses, as well as for restricted properties without the favorable opinion of the authority responsible for protection.
On the basis of the consolidated jurisprudence of the Court of Cassation and the Council of State on the third amnesty, in fact, in areas subject to landscape, environmental or hydrogeological restrictions, the 2003 amnesty remains precluded for all major abuses (new constructions and volumetric expansions), even if the restriction was imposed after the construction of the work. In these areas the art. 32 allows only minor restoration, conservative rehabilitation and extraordinary maintenance interventions to be condoned, subject to the favorable opinion of the authority responsible for protection.
Comparison between ordinary amnesties and reopening of the 2003 amnesty: table
Here, in summary, is the current status of the amnesties provided for by the Consolidated Building Act (Presidential Decree 380/2001) and those provided for by the 2003 amnesty:
|
Characteristic |
Strict double compliance (Art. 36 TEU) |
Simplified amnesty (Art. 36-bis TEU) |
Extraordinary amnesty (Art. 32 DL 269/2003) |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Nature of the norm |
Ordinary (always in force). |
Ordinary (always in force). |
Extraordinary and temporary (limited window for questions about old abuse). |
|
Kind of abuse |
Serious but regular abuse in substance (absence of permission or total non-compliance). |
Minor / formal abuse (partial discrepancies, essential variations, absence of SCIA). |
Substantial abuses (expansions of up to 30% or 750 m3 and new buildings of up to 750 m3 in derogation from the plans). |
|
Urban planning rules (master plans, indexes) |
Respect required both at the time of the works and today. |
Respect required only today (at the time of application). |
Derogated (in exchange for payment of oblation and concession charges). |
|
Building rules (technical, hygiene, seismic) |
Respect required both at the time of the works and today. |
Respect required only at the time of the works (except for any requirements). |
Derogated, but seismic and static suitability remains mandatory. |
|
Deadline for works |
None (valid for interventions carried out at any time). |
None (valid for interventions carried out at any time). |
Mandatory: works completed by 31 March 2003. |
|
Limits and constraints |
It never repairs works prohibited by urban planning plans. |
It never cures total abuses or increases in volume not permitted today. |
Excluding areas with absolute no-build restrictions, cultural heritage, state property, civic uses and areas affected by fires. |
>> If you want to receive news like this directly on your smartphone, subscribe to our new Telegram channel!
Thank you for subscribing to the newsletter.