Selective glass: how to choose the right balance between natural light and solar control

|

Emma Potter

The choice of glass surfaces has a decisive role in energy behavior and living comfort: a glass window must in fact help to contain heat loss in winter and limit overheating in summer, without compromising the natural lighting of the rooms.

In this context, selective glass represents a particularly interesting solution, since it allows the entry of solar radiation to be controlled while maintaining a significant part of the light transmission. However, choosing a glass window solely on the basis of its energy performance can lead to unsatisfactory results in terms of living comfort.

Selective glass: how it works and why it is important

To understand the functioning of selective glasses it is necessary to distinguish the different components of electromagnetic radiation. As Tessiore explains, solar radiation includes visible light, ultraviolet radiation and short-wave infrared radiation. Heated bodies, on the other hand, mainly emit long-wave infrared radiation. This distinction is fundamental to understanding the behavior of glass surfaces and the phenomenon commonly referred to as the greenhouse effect.

The solar radiation that passes through a glass window is partly absorbed by the elements present in the internal environment, which heat up and return energy in the form of long-wave infrared radiation. Glass hinders the transmission of this radiation to the outside, contributing to the rise of the internal temperature.

Selective glass is designed to reduce the energy component of solar radiation that passes through the glass, while trying to maintain adequate transmission of visible light. However, their effectiveness cannot be assessed through a single parameter: it is necessary to simultaneously consider the thermal behavior, solar control and the quantity of light transmitted.

Solar factor g, light transmittance TL and transmittance Ug

In the chapter dedicated to the fundamental sizes of glazing, Tessiore identifies three particularly important parameters for the choice of selective glass.

The first is the solar factor g, which represents the ratio between the total solar energy transmitted inside and that incident on the glass. The value includes both the directly transmitted solar radiation component and the part of the energy absorbed by the glass and subsequently released into the internal environment. A low g value therefore makes it possible to reduce solar gains and the consequent risk of overheating the rooms.

The second parameter is the light transmission TL, expressed as a percentage, which indicates the ratio between the quantity of visible light incident on the glass and that actually transmitted inside. The higher the TL, the greater, all other conditions being equal, the amount of natural light that passes through the glass.

The third parameter is the thermal transmittance Ug, expressed in W/m²K, which measures the heat losses through the glass in the presence of a temperature difference between inside and outside. A lower Ug value corresponds to a greater insulating capacity.

These three quantities describe different performances: Ug mainly concerns thermal insulation, g the control of solar gains and TL the lighting comfort. For this reason they must be evaluated together, especially when selective glass or particularly high-performance insulating glass is used.

Selective glass and natural light: what changes with the different stratigraphies

One of the most interesting aspects addressed in the volume concerns the reduction in light transmission that can accompany the improvement in the performance of glazing. The author proposes a comparison between different stratigraphies, showing how the quantity of transmitted light can change significantly.

Type of glass

Ug (W/m²K)

TL

3 mm monolithic float glass

5.8

91%

Double glazing 4-12-4

2.8

83%

Low-E double glazing

1.0

72%

Triple low-e glazing

0.5

59%

Double glazing with selective 60/28

1.0

60%

Triple glazing with selective 60/28 and low emissivity

0.5

49%

The data highlights how two windows with the same thermal transmittance can have very different light transmission values.

For example, a low-E double glazing with Ug equal to 1.0 W/m²K has a TL of 72%, while a selective double glazing with the same Ug value can have a TL of 60%. The difference becomes even more evident when comparing some triple solutions.

This aspect takes on particular importance in window replacement interventions, when the window surface remains unchanged. The improvement in thermal performance can in fact be accompanied by a reduction in available natural light, with consequences on occupant comfort and the use of artificial lighting.

How to choose selective glass without penalizing lighting comfort

According to the approach proposed by the author, the choice of glass must start from the specific needs of the building and not from the search for the most favorable single performance parameter. Solar control is particularly important to contain overheating, but the effects on the brightness of the rooms must also be evaluated.

The light transmission does not only depend on the selective treatment, but also on the number of sheets, their thickness, the composition of the stratigraphy and the presence of any laminated safety glass. It follows that each solution must be evaluated in its actual configuration.

The author also recalls the importance of the average daylight factor, used to evaluate the availability of natural lighting in environments. In fact, simply knowing the percentage of light transmission is not sufficient to describe the lighting conditions of a room.

The dimensions of the windows, the characteristics of the environment and the exposure conditions must also be considered in the design.

Further attention concerns internal light reflection, which can increase with the use of glass with particular surface treatments. In certain conditions, especially in the evening hours with internal lighting on, this phenomenon can compromise visibility towards the outside.

The correct selection of glass therefore requires an overall evaluation, capable of balancing sun protection, thermal insulation, natural lighting and visual comfort.

The checks to be carried out before choosing selective glazing

To identify the most suitable solution, it is essential to carefully examine the performance characteristics declared in the technical documentation of the glass. The author highlights the importance of verifying the values ​​relating to thermal, energetic and luminous properties, avoiding relying exclusively on the commercial names of the products.

In particular, for selective glass it is advisable to consider the solar factor g, the light transmission TL and the transmittance Ug, checking that the values ​​refer to the stratigraphy actually foreseen. Consultation of technical data sheets and the use of configuration tools allow you to compare different solutions and evaluate their performance before making a final choice.

The principle to follow is clear: the best glass is not necessarily the one with the lowest solar factor or the lowest thermal transmittance, but the one that responds in a balanced way to the needs of the building. The design of glass surfaces therefore requires considering energy performance together with the quality of natural light, avoiding the improvement of a single characteristic resulting in a worsening of overall comfort.

For further information: the volume Glass in construction by Elvio Tessiore

As anticipated, this article takes up the contents of the chapters dedicated to the relationship between glass, light and heat of the volume Glass in construction. Everything about insulating glass, structural glass and active glassby Elvio Tessiore, published by Maggioli Editore.

The manual addresses the main issues related to the use of glass in buildings with a technical and operational approach: from the energy and luminous performance of insulating glass to structural and safety aspects, up to building pathologies and active glass. The work offers designers, window and door fitters, construction managers and technicians useful tools for interpreting product characteristics, correctly choosing glazing and preventing design errors.