Short-term or tourist rentals and urban planning limitations between European, national and regional legislation

|

Emma Potter

The terms overtourism or gentrification, in relation to short-term or tourist rentals, have now entered common use. But why deal with it on this site?

The Court of Justice of the European Union

The Court of Justice of the European Union, with ruling C-813/24 of October 2026 (downloadable at the end of this contribution)clarified that local planning regulations on short-term rentals fall within Directive 2006/123/EC (better known as the “Bolkestein Directive”) when they affect access to the accommodation business.

To better understand the point of arrival of the sentence it is necessary, with the greatest possible conciseness, to start from the controversy which originates from a Belgian case in which a company had received an injunction to cease its activity for having managed short-term tourist accommodation without prior registration and without the necessary certificates. In particular, the company had not managed to obtain the fire safety certificate as the local authorities (it was the Brussels Region) had requested a prior change of intended use (from “accommodation” to “hotel facility”) based on the reference urban planning instruments.

Having said this, the ruling of the Court of Justice has established some key points on the matter. First of all, the applicability of the Bolkestein Directive to the urban planning regulations that regulate the change of use of properties was recognized when these, interpreted together with the tourism regulations, condition the access and exercise of a service activity within which the temporary rental falls.

Secondly, the ruling affirmed the legitimacy of the prior authorization regime linked to the protection of tourists and the urban environment, also to make up for the well-known shortage of residential accommodation due precisely to the phenomena of overtourism and gentrification that we talked about in the introduction. However, it is up to the national judge to verify their proportionality by excluding the applicability of such restrictions if the accommodation remains the manager’s main residence; in this case, in fact, there is no impact on the long-term rental market.

Therefore, the discretionary power of the Municipalities, although legitimate as mentioned, is only permitted if it is exercised on the basis of transparent, objective and unambiguous criteria, so as to avoid arbitrary decisions or decisions based on criteria of mere convenience. Consequently, the relevant authorization procedure must be concluded in certain terms with the possibility of protecting one’s reasons before a judge.

Ultimately, if the urban planning provision conflicts with the Bolkestein Directive and can be separated from the rest of the regulation, the national judge must disapply only that specific condition, while otherwise, i.e. if it has a preponderant effectiveness, the entire authorization ceases.

The Constitutional Court

The ruling of the Constitutional Court of 9 October 2026, n. 164 (also downloadable at the end of this contribution)instead, it dealt with the articles. 4 and 5 of the regional law (Emilia-Romagna) 19 December 2025, n. 10 on the subject of short-term rentals, declaring their constitutional illegitimacy.

The matter, in this case, originates from the appeal of the Presidency of the Council of Ministers against regional law no. 10/2025 which provided for urban planning and construction regulations for properties intended for rentals of less than 30 days. In particular, with art. 4, “short-term rental” was identified as a specific and autonomous urban planning use destination within the tourist-accommodation category.

Consequently, anyone wishing to rent an apartment for short periods was obliged to obtain a change of urban use at least through SCIA. In turn, art. 5 allowed Municipalities to include stringent limits or conditions in their urban planning instruments (e.g. percentage ceilings for apartments, subdivision bans, requests for appurtenant standards) to slow down the establishment of short-term rentals in the area.

The ruling takes a position on the multiple aspects of the matter and, first and foremost, on the legislative competence to which the subject of the dispute falls. In particular, the Court specified that the matter does not belong to the “protection of competition“in which the State has exclusive legislative power, but rather to matters “territorial government” And “tourism” in which the Regions with ordinary statute have concurrent legislative power.

Furthermore, the Constitutional Court, along the lines of the indications of the European Court of Justice in terms of reasonable limitations on rentals, has therefore turned its attention to the articles. 3 and 41 of the Constitution, verifying whether the legitimate regional objectives of stemming the expulsion of residents and the increase in rents caused from overtourism in cities were based on proportionality and reasonableness with respect to the limits imposed on non-hotel facilities.

Well, in the opinion of the Court, the articles. 4 and 5 of regional law n. 10/2025 were declared unconstitutional because, while in Emilia-Romagna the structures operating in a stable entrepreneurial form, such as theguest house” or the “holiday homes and apartments” (so-called “CAV”), could maintain the intended residential use, a change of urban use was imposed only on short-term rentals, even when they were exercised in a non-entrepreneurial form or in a completely sporadic and occasional manner.

Hence the unreasonable disparity in treatment to the detriment of only short-term landlords compared to other non-hotel accommodation facilities.

Conclusions

Now, faced with these interpretations of jurisprudence, the disorientation of citizens and operators (private or public in the sector) is amply justified.

The hope is that the national legislator will address the issue by defining, at a regulatory level, what is meant by short-term or tourist rental, not indirectly (with the use of sector regulations) and in which of the urban planning functions pursuant to art. 23-ter, Consolidated Construction Law, it must be placed.

Read and download the sentences here: